Rentology Resources

Innago Alternative: Free vs Paid Landlord Software Compared

By Ingo Schaer, founder of Rentology · Updated 2026

A hand holding house keys over small model houses Photo: @jakubzerdzicki on Unsplash

Key takeaways

  • Innago charges landlords nothing: "No monthly fee. No setup fee. No contract." It earns from tenants: $2 per bank (ACH) payment, 2.99% per card payment, and $30-35 per screening (Innago pricing, Innago FAQ).
  • RentRedi charges the landlord instead: $29.95 a month, or $12 a month billed yearly, with unlimited units (RentRedi pricing).
  • TurboTenant has a free plan and paid plans from $149 a year for 1-10 units; its page shows renter fees of free or $2 for bank transfer and 3.49% for cards depending on the plan (TurboTenant pricing).
  • Landlord Studio is free for 3 units, then $15 a month with $1.20 per extra unit (Landlord Studio pricing).
  • "Free" moves the cost to your tenant. For 10 tenants paying by bank transfer, Innago's fee adds up to $240 a year paid by them.

What Innago is, and why people look for an alternative

Innago is property management software for independent landlords. Its pricing page says it is free for landlords, with no monthly fee, no setup fee and no contract (Innago pricing). Its FAQ says how it pays for itself: small fees on tenants. Bank payments cost the tenant $2 each, card payments 2.99%, and screening $30-35 per applicant, with income verification $10 more (Innago FAQ).

That is a fair deal for many owners. People look for an alternative for three main reasons:

  1. Tenant pushback. Some tenants do not want to pay $2 to pay rent. If you absorb it, Innago is no longer free.
  2. Missing pieces. Owners who add a furnished home, a short-term rental or a room rental find a lease-only tool too narrow.
  3. Growth. At 30 or 50 units, owners start wanting accounting, owner statements or team roles that a free tool might not cover.

Name your reason first. Each one points to a different kind of alternative.

Free versus paid: who pays is the real question

Every tool here costs money. The difference is who sends it.

Tool Landlord pays Tenant pays (from vendor page) Unit limits
Innago $0 $2 per ACH, 2.99% card, $30-35 screening None stated
TurboTenant Free, or from $149/yr (Essentials) or $199/yr (Pro) for 1-10 units ACH free or $2, card 3.49%, screening $45 or $55, by plan Priced in unit bands
RentRedi $29.95/mo, $20/mo (6-month) or $12/mo (yearly) Screening $39.99, or $49.99 with income check Unlimited
Landlord Studio Free (3 units), Pro $15/mo, Pro Plus $35/mo Not listed on pricing page 3 included, $1.20 per extra
Buildium From $65/mo Card 2.99%; ACH fee charged per plan Over 5,000 units call

Sources: Innago, TurboTenant, RentRedi, Landlord Studio, Buildium. Prices were read on each vendor's page for this article; check again before you sign.

A worked example: 10 units, one year

Example: 10 tenants, all paying by bank transfer, 12 payments each, so 120 payments a year. Two new tenants a year, three applicants each.

  • Innago: landlord pays $0. Tenants pay 120 x $2 = $240 in payment fees, plus 6 x $30-35 = $180-210 in screening. If you choose to cover the payment fees yourself, your cost is $240.
  • RentRedi, yearly: landlord pays 12 x $12 = $144. Applicants pay 6 x $39.99 = $239.94 for screening.
  • TurboTenant Essentials: landlord pays $149 for 1-10 units. Bank transfers are free or $2 depending on plan, so tenants pay between $0 and $240.
  • Landlord Studio Pro, yearly: $144 covers 3 units; 7 extra units x $1.20 = $8.40 (the page does not say if that is per month; if it is, $100.80 a year). Total about $152-$245.

On these numbers, the "free" tool and the paid tools land within about $100 of each other. The difference is whether you or your tenant writes the check.

So pick on features and tenant experience, not on the word "free".

The alternatives, one by one

TurboTenant

TurboTenant's free plan covers listing and marketing your rental, screening applicants and collecting rent online. Essentials starts at $149 a year for 1-10 units and Pro at $199 a year for 1-10 units, with higher bands at 11-30, 31-60 and 61+ units. Renters pay screening ($45 or $55) and card fees (3.49%), and the bank transfer fee shows as free on one schedule and $2 on the other (TurboTenant pricing).

Fit: owners who want a free start and a clear yearly price when they grow.

RentRedi

RentRedi has one feature set at three billing terms: $29.95 monthly, $20 a month on six-month billing, or $12 a month billed yearly. Every plan includes unlimited properties, tenants, teammates and bank accounts, with no per-unit fees. Screening is paid by the tenant: $39.99, or $49.99 with income verification (RentRedi pricing).

Fit: owners who would rather pay one flat yearly fee than pass fees to tenants.

Landlord Studio

Landlord Studio's Go plan is free for 3 units and 1 user. Pro is $15 a month ($12 billed yearly) with 3 users, and Pro Plus is $35 a month ($28 yearly) with 10 users; both include 3 units and charge $1.20 per extra unit. Pro has a 14-day trial with no card (Landlord Studio pricing).

Fit: owners who care most about bookkeeping and tax reports.

Buildium

Buildium is a step up in size and price. Essential is $65 a month, Growth $202 and Premium $420. Incoming bank payments cost $2.35, $1.35 or $0.60 each by plan, and card payments 2.99% (Buildium pricing).

Fit: managers with owners to report to, staff to coordinate and a budget to match.

A person working at a calculator with coffee, adding up yearly software costs Photo: @towfiqu999999 on Unsplash

When none of these fit: mixed rentals

All four alternatives above are built around 12-month leases. That is most landlords. But a growing number of owners run more than one kind of stay: a lease in one home, a furnished home for month-long stays, maybe a short-term rental.

The furnished month is worth a look. In the homes our team manages, 50 of 616 stays in one year were 28 nights or longer, and those stays brought in 51% of rental revenue. Month-long stays were booked about 10 days before arrival.

A lease-only tool can hold the lease but not the calendar, the cleaning or the guest messages. If that is your situation, look for software that holds short, mid and long-term rentals in one account, with leases and monthly payments for furnished stays. Rentology is built that way. The free rental income calculator gives a first figure for what a furnished month could earn in your home.

How to choose an Innago alternative, step by step

  1. Write down your reason for leaving. Tenant fees, missing features or growth. Keep it to one line.
  2. Decide who should pay for payments. If tenants, a tenant-fee tool is fine. If you, compare flat fees.
  3. List the five jobs you do every month. Usually rent, reminders, maintenance requests, messages and bookkeeping.
  4. Check each vendor's own pricing page for those five jobs and the plan that includes them.
  5. Run your numbers like the example above, with your unit count and payment mix.
  6. Try two tools with real tenants. Invite one or two tenants who will tell you honestly how paying felt.
  7. Move at a month boundary. Switch rent collection after one month's rent clears, so nobody pays twice.

What to compare beyond price

How fast rent reaches you

Bank transfers take days to clear, and timing differs by tool and payment type. Ask each vendor how many business days pass between a tenant paying and the money landing in your account, and whether that changes for first-time payers.

Screening

Check what the report includes (credit, criminal, eviction, income) and who pays. Applicant-paid screening is common; the price and the depth vary.

Maintenance requests

Tenants should be able to send a request with photos from a phone. You should see open requests in one list, with dates, so nothing sits for a week.

Bookkeeping and tax

At year end you need income and expenses per property. Look for categories that match the lines on your tax return and an export your accountant can open. Separate repairs from improvements during the year: repairs can be deducted, while improvements must be capitalized and depreciated (IRS Publication 527), and fixing it later is slow.

Leaving later

Ask how you export your data if you move again: payment history, leases and documents. A tool that makes leaving hard makes every price rise harder to refuse.

What to ask tenants before you switch

Your tenants live with your choice every month. Ask them:

  • Do you prefer bank transfer or card?
  • Would a $2 fee on each payment bother you?
  • Do you want to pay from a phone app or a web page?
  • Do you need receipts for a housing program or an employer?

A tool tenants like gets paid on time. A tool they resent gets "the payment did not go through" messages.

Common mistakes

  • Treating "free" as free. The cost moves to tenants, or to you if you absorb it.
  • Forgetting screening fees. At $30 to $55 an applicant, they add up fast when a unit gets many applicants.
  • Switching mid-month. Two systems both sending rent reminders confuse tenants and cause double payments.
  • Choosing on price alone. A $100-a-year difference matters less than one missed rent payment.
  • Leaving history behind. Export payment records, leases and maintenance notes before you close the old account.

Questions

Is Innago really free?

For landlords, yes: no monthly fee, no setup fee and no contract. Tenants pay $2 per bank payment and 2.99% per card payment, and applicants pay $30-35 for screening (Innago FAQ).

What is the best free alternative to Innago?

TurboTenant and Landlord Studio both have free plans. TurboTenant's covers listing, screening and online rent; Landlord Studio's covers 3 units and 1 user (TurboTenant, Landlord Studio).

Which alternative avoids fees for tenants?

Look for a plan where bank transfers are free to the renter. TurboTenant's page shows a free bank transfer on one of its renter fee schedules (TurboTenant pricing). RentRedi's pricing page does not list rent payment fees, so ask before you choose.

Is Buildium a good Innago alternative?

For a small landlord, Buildium costs more: from $65 a month plus per-payment fees (Buildium pricing). It makes sense when you manage for other owners or need staff roles.

Can these tools handle furnished or short-term rentals?

The pricing pages for Innago, TurboTenant, RentRedi and Landlord Studio talk about leases and rent, not nightly bookings. If you run furnished or short-term stays, check for a calendar, cleaning and guest messages before you switch.

Sources

  1. Innago pricing
  2. Innago FAQ
  3. TurboTenant pricing
  4. RentRedi pricing
  5. Landlord Studio pricing
  6. Buildium pricing
  7. IRS Publication 527, Residential Rental Property

Loading…