Airbnb vs long-term rental

    Airbnb usually grosses the most and takes the most work. A lease grosses the least and takes the least. Most owners never price the option in between: a furnished stay of 30 nights or more.

    What would your address earn?

    Enter a street address and compare all three for that home, with the source under every number. Free, no sign-up.

    Ingo Schaer

    By Ingo Schaer · Updated 2026

    Founder of Rentology. Runs furnished month-long, nightly and long-term rentals with his team.

    A white house with trees, the kind of home an owner can rent nightly, by the month or on a lease
    Photo: @philhearing on Unsplash

    The short answer

    Airbnb usually earns more per month than a 12-month lease, and it takes much more work, money and risk to earn it. A lease earns less, steadily, with one renter, one move-in and one set of rules from state landlord law. The choice is not only between those two. A furnished stay of 30 nights or more sits between them: more than a lease, less work than nightly guests.

    So the honest question for your home is: after the extra costs and hours, is the nightly gross far enough above the lease and the furnished month to be worth it? This guide walks through the income, the costs, the work, the risk and the rules, then shows a worked example you can redo with your own numbers.

    Three ways to rent the same home

    TypeStayWho rentsIncome and work
    Short-termUnder 30 nightsTourists, weekend and business tripsHighest per night, most work
    Mid-term30 nights to a few monthsNurses, relocating staff, insured familiesUsually well above a lease, few turnovers
    Long-term12 months or moreResidentsLowest per month, least work

    Short-term means stays under 30 nights, booked mostly by tourists and business travellers. Mid-term means 30 nights to a few months, booked by travel nurses, staff on a project or a move, and families an insurer is housing after damage to their own home. Long-term means a lease of 12 months or more, usually unfurnished, rented by a resident.

    The 30-night line matters beyond the label. Many cities regulate rentals under 30 nights as short-term rentals and treat longer stays like ordinary tenancies, and Airbnb itself handles payouts differently for stays of 28 nights or more (how payouts work for longer stays).

    What each one grosses, city by city

    Airbnb gross vs 12-month lease, 12 highest cities, 2026
    Airbnb, gross12-month lease
    1. San Francisco, CA$3,950
    2. Boston, MA$3,510
    3. Cambridge, MA$3,510
    4. San Diego, CA$3,240
    5. New Orleans, LA$3,150
    6. Chicago, IL$2,870
    7. Nashville, TN$2,860
    8. Bozeman, MT$2,820
    9. New York, NY$2,810
    10. Jersey City, NJ$2,800
    11. Honolulu, HI$2,790
    12. Seattle, WA$2,680
    City
    San Francisco, CA$3,750$7,500$3,950
    Boston, MA$2,650$5,300$3,510
    Cambridge, MA$2,800$5,600$3,510
    San Diego, CA$2,750$5,500$3,240
    New Orleans, LA$1,590$3,180$3,150
    Chicago, IL$1,750$3,500$2,870
    Nashville, TN$1,880$3,760$2,860
    Bozeman, MT$1,880$3,760$2,820
    New York, NY$2,440$4,880$2,810
    Jersey City, NJ$2,260$4,520$2,800
    Honolulu, HI$2,500$5,000$2,790
    Seattle, WA$2,710$5,420$2,680
    Newark, NJ$1,970$3,940$2,590
    Los Angeles, CA$2,550$5,100$2,520
    Portland, OR$2,100$4,200$2,480

    Two bedrooms, per month. Lease: US Census county medians at the 2026 level. Furnished: twice the lease. Airbnb: median gross of the listings near the city centre, Inside Airbnb 2026, before cleaning and fees.

    Two-bedroom homes, gross per month, before any cost. The lease column is the median 12-month rent from the US Census Bureau's American Community Survey, brought to the current year with the Bureau of Labor Statistics rent index. The furnished column is the start point owners use for stays of 30 nights or more: twice the lease. The Airbnb column is the median monthly gross per active listing from Inside Airbnb's public data.

    Read the table as a gap, not a winner. Where Airbnb is far above the furnished figure, nightly can pay for its extra work. Where the two sit close, the furnished month often nets more once cleaning, fees, supplies and empty nights come off. Sort any column to see where your city lands.

    What comes off each number

    Gross is the wrong number to compare. Each way of renting carries its own costs, and nightly carries the most.

    Nightly Airbnb

    • Platform fee: most hosts pay 15.5% under Airbnb's single host-paid fee, charged on the nightly price plus cleaning and other host fees; the older split fee of about 3% is being phased out (Airbnb service fees).
    • A clean after every stay. Ten stays a month means ten cleans, plus linens and restocking.
    • Utilities, internet, streaming and supplies, all paid by you.
    • Furnishing to a guest standard, and replacing what wears out quickly.
    • Empty nights. Even good listings have gaps, mostly midweek and in the slow season.
    • Local taxes and permit fees where your city charges them.

    Furnished month (30+ nights)

    • One clean at the end of each stay instead of every few nights.
    • Utilities and internet, usually included in the rent.
    • Furnishing, though wear is slower with one renter at a time.
    • A listing fee where you advertise; for example Furnished Finder charges owners $199 a year per listing on its current pricing page.
    • A few empty days between renters.

    12-month lease

    • Usually no furnishing and no utilities; the tenant pays them.
    • Repairs, and a turnover every year or two: paint, cleaning, a month or so empty while you find the next tenant.
    • Screening costs and, if you use one, a leasing or management fee.
    A calculator next to a laptop, for working out what each kind of rental nets
    Photo: @jakubzerdzicki on Unsplash

    A worked example with simple numbers

    The numbers below are an example to show the method, not a forecast for any city. Put your own figures from the table and your own quotes in their place.

    Worked example: one two-bedroom, three ways

    Lease: $1,600 a month, tenant pays utilities. Net before repairs: $1,600. Furnished month: $3,200 (twice the lease), minus $250 utilities and internet, minus one $150 clean = $2,800. Nightly: $4,200 gross, minus 15.5% Airbnb fee ($651), minus 8 cleans at $100 ($800), minus $300 utilities and supplies = $2,449. In this example the furnished month nets $351 more than nightly with one clean instead of eight, and $1,200 more than the lease. Change the nightly gross to $5,500 and nightly nets about $3,548, so it wins. The gap decides.

    The work each one takes

    Hours are a real cost even when you do the work yourself. Count them honestly before you compare.

    • Nightly: pricing every night, answering guests before, during and after each stay at any hour, a clean and check after every checkout, restocking, reviews, and a new door code or key handover each time.
    • Furnished month: finding and screening each renter, a short lease, one move-in and one move-out walk-through, monthly rent collection and the occasional repair.
    • Lease: screening once a year or less, a standard lease, rent collection and repairs. Of the three, it takes the fewest hours.

    Risk and the rules

    City rules

    Many cities require a permit or registration for stays under 30 nights, limit how many nights a year a home can be rented that way, or allow it only in your main home. Stays of 30 nights or more are often outside those rules. Check your city and county before you choose, and check your HOA or condo rules too.

    Tenant law

    A stay of 30 nights or more can count as a tenancy under state law. That brings deposit rules, notice periods and, if things go wrong, a formal eviction. A 12-month lease is a tenancy from day one. Know your state's rules before you sign anything.

    Fair housing

    Long and mid-term rentals are housing, so the federal Fair Housing Act applies: use the same written screening criteria for every applicant.

    Insurance

    A standard landlord policy often does not cover paying nightly guests. Ask your insurer in writing which use your policy covers, and read what Airbnb's own host protection does and does not cover (AirCover for Hosts).

    Income swings

    Nightly income moves with the season and with the market around you. A lease pays the same every month. A furnished month sits between: steady for the length of each stay, with a gap to fill between renters.

    Local rules first

    Check your city's short-term rental rules, your HOA and your insurance before you choose. A strong nightly number is worth nothing in a city that does not allow nightly stays at your address.

    How to decide for your home, step by step

    1. Find your city in the table above and write down the three monthly figures for a two-bedroom; adjust for your bedroom count and condition.
    2. Check your city's rules for stays under 30 nights, your HOA and your insurance. If nightly is not allowed, compare only the furnished month and the lease.
    3. Subtract the costs for each option using real quotes: cleaner, utilities, platform fees, furnishing spread over three years.
    4. Estimate your hours per month for each option and put a price on them, even if it is your own time.
    5. Compare the net figures. If nightly is not clearly ahead after costs and hours, the furnished month or the lease is the better choice.
    6. Consider a mix: nightly in the busy season, furnished stays of 30 nights or more in the slow season, where your city allows both.
    7. Review once a year. Rents, nightly prices and local rules all move.

    When each one fits best

    • Nightly fits a home in a busy tourist or event area, in a city that allows it, with an owner or manager who can answer guests fast and line up cleans after every stay.
    • A furnished month fits a home near hospitals, large employers or a university, in a city that restricts nightly stays, or an owner who wants more than a lease with far fewer turnovers.
    • A lease fits an owner who wants the fewest hours and the steadiest income, or a home far from where travellers and project workers go.
    A made bed with white linen, ready for a furnished stay
    Photo: @vojtechbruzek on Unsplash

    Common mistakes

    • Comparing gross to gross. A nightly figure before fees, cleans and empty nights is not what you keep.
    • Pricing a furnished month as 30 nightly rates. That is far above what month-long renters pay, and the home sits empty.
    • Skipping the rules check. Fines and forced cancellations wipe out any gap.
    • Ignoring the hours. Nightly hosting is a daily job; if you will pay someone to do it, include that fee.
    • Thinking it must be all or nothing. Many owners mix nightly and month-long stays across the year.

    What we saw running real homes

    In one year across the homes our team manages, 50 of 616 stays were 28 nights or longer, and those 50 stays brought in 51% of the rental revenue. They needed 50 cleans, where the same nights as short stays would have needed hundreds, and they filled the weeks that nightly guests left empty. Month-long stays were booked about ten days before arrival on average, so they work well as a way to fill gaps at short notice.

    Most of those renters did not find the homes on their own. They came through hospitals, employers and insurers. Rentology's Company Outreach finds the hospitals, employers and insurers near each home, writes the first email, follows up, and puts the replies in one inbox.

    How we built this data

    • Lease rents: the median gross rent by number of bedrooms for each city's county from the US Census Bureau's American Community Survey, brought forward to the 2026 level with the federal rent index from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Gross rent includes utilities the tenant pays.
    • Furnished month-long rent: twice the lease, the low end of the 2 to 2.2 times range owners use for stays of 30 nights or more. A start point to price from, not a quote.
    • Airbnb figures: the median of the Airbnb listings near each city centre from Inside Airbnb, an independent project that publishes listing snapshots and estimates booked nights from reviews. Gross, before Airbnb's fee, cleaning and taxes.
    • Every figure is read from our stored copy of these sources when the page loads. We reload all of them once a year, and the year on each table says which one you are reading.

    Questions

    Is Airbnb more profitable than a long-term rental?
    It grosses more in most large US cities, but fees, cleaning, utilities, furnishing and empty nights come off. Compare the net figures and your hours, not the gross.
    What is the difference between short-term and long-term rentals?
    Short-term is under 30 nights, usually tourists. Long-term is a lease of 12 months or more. Mid-term, 30 nights to a few months, sits between them.
    What is a good middle option between Airbnb and a lease?
    A furnished stay of 30 nights or more. Owners usually start it at about twice the 12-month lease, and it needs one clean per stay instead of one every few nights.
    How much does Airbnb take from hosts?
    Airbnb is moving all hosts to a single host-paid fee: most hosts pay 15.5% (some 14% to 16%) of the nightly price plus cleaning and other host fees, and the guest sees no separate service fee. The older split fee of about 3% is being phased out. Check Airbnb's current terms for your listing.
    Can I switch from Airbnb to a long-term rental later?
    Yes. Many owners move between them as rules, prices or their own time change. A furnished month is an easy step between the two because the home is already furnished.
    Do I need a permit for Airbnb but not for a lease?
    Often, yes. Many cities require a permit or registration for stays under 30 nights and not for longer ones. Check your city and county rules.

    Sources

    1. US Census Bureau, American Community Survey: rent by bedrooms (B25031)
    2. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI rent of primary residence
    3. Inside Airbnb: get the data: public listing data behind the Airbnb column
    4. Airbnb: service fees
    5. Airbnb: how payouts work for longer stays
    6. Furnished Finder pricing for property owners
    7. US Department of Justice: the Fair Housing Act
    8. Airbnb: AirCover for Hosts
    9. US Census Bureau, American Community Survey program
    10. Inside Airbnb: how the data is collected and estimated

    Why owners run their rentals with Rentology

    Rentology runs leases, furnished stays of 30 nights or more and nightly stays from one place: the calendar, the lease, the monthly payment and the cleaning between stays.

    Company Outreach finds the hospitals, employers and insurers near each of your homes and writes to them for you, so month-long renters come to you.

    • It finds the hospitals, companies and insurers near your homes that book month-long stays, and writes to them for you
    • Answers guests for you, day and night
    • One calendar for every home and every booking
    • Cleaner schedule, door codes and photo inspections for every stay
    • Owner statements and an owner portal, if you manage homes for others

    What 3 homes usually pay each month for the tools Rentology replaces

    • AI guest messaging · HostBuddy$30
    • Cleaning scheduling · Turno$30
    • Phone and AI receptionist · Quo Business + Sona$58
    • Social media scheduling · Buffer Team$30
    • Reels and images · Canva$12
    • E-signature · DocuSign Business Pro$40
    • Team chat · Slack Pro$8.75
    • Dynamic pricing · PriceLabs$22.47
    • Team tasks · Asana Starter$10.99
    • These tools together$242.21
    • Rentology, 3 homes, everything inside$149
    • What you save every month$93.21

    List prices of the named tools in US dollars, per month. Your own booking website, digital guidebooks, work orders and the owner portal are inside Rentology at no extra cost.

    No card. Your first home is set up in about ten minutes.