Tenant screening

    Good screening is the same written test for every applicant, run with their consent. It protects the home and keeps you on the right side of fair housing law.

    Ingo Schaer

    By Ingo Schaer · Updated 2026

    Founder of Rentology. Runs furnished month-long, nightly and long-term rentals with his team.

    A person writing on paper while reviewing a rental application
    Photo: @cytonn_photography on Unsplash

    What tenant screening is

    Tenant screening is how a landlord decides whether an applicant is likely to pay rent on time, look after the home and follow the lease. It combines what the applicant tells you, what their documents show, what past landlords say, and what consumer reports contain.

    Screening protects the home, but it also carries legal duties. Federal law controls how you get and use credit and background reports and bans discrimination against protected groups. State and city laws often add more, such as limits on application fees, on how criminal records can be used, or on using a source of income like a housing voucher to say no.

    This is general information, not legal advice. Check your state and city rules, and ask a local attorney if you are unsure about a specific decision.

    The usual checks

    Income

    Many landlords look for gross monthly income of about three times the rent. Ask for recent pay stubs, an offer letter for a new job, or bank statements and tax returns for self-employed applicants. Some applicants have savings or a co-signer instead of income; decide in advance whether you accept those, and write it down.

    Rental history

    Call the last one or two landlords. Ask whether rent was paid on time, whether the tenant gave notice, the condition the home was left in, and whether they would rent to them again. Confirm the landlord is real: a property record or a management company number is better than a phone number on the application.

    Credit report

    A credit report shows payment history, debts and collections. Look for patterns, not a single score: a medical collection tells you less than a string of unpaid rental or utility accounts. Many screening services give a summary built for landlords.

    Eviction and public records

    Eviction filings and judgments show past disputes. A filing is not a judgment; many are dismissed. Some states and cities limit how old records or sealed cases can be used.

    Criminal background

    If you check criminal records, use a written policy that looks at the nature, severity and age of an offense and how it relates to the safety of residents and property. A blanket ban on anyone with a record can create fair housing risk, and many states and cities set their own limits.

    Identity

    Match a photo ID to the applicant in person or on a video call, and to the name on the reports. Rental fraud often starts with a real person's stolen details.

    A person working on a laptop at a wooden desk while reviewing applications
    Photo: @microsoftcopilot on Unsplash

    Write your criteria down before you list

    The single best protection, for you and the applicant, is a short written policy you set before the first inquiry. It makes decisions faster, keeps them consistent, and gives you a record if a decision is ever questioned.

    • Minimum income, as a multiple of rent, and what counts as income.
    • What rental history you need, and what you do with no history at all.
    • The credit and eviction record you accept, and over what time.
    • How you treat criminal records, if you check them at all.
    • Maximum occupants, within local occupancy codes.
    • Pets, with a note that assistance animals are not pets.
    • The application fee, if any, and what it pays for. Some states cap it.
    • First complete application, first reviewed: the order you process applications.

    Fair housing: the decisions you cannot make

    The federal Fair Housing Act bans refusing to rent, setting different terms, or advertising a preference based on race, color, religion, sex, national origin, disability or familial status. The text is in 42 USC 3604. Many states and cities add more protected groups, such as age, marital status or source of income.

    • Do not ask about or decide on any protected trait. Ask the same questions of every applicant.
    • Write listings about the home, not about the ideal renter: say "two bedrooms near the hospital", not "perfect for a young professional".
    • Make reasonable accommodations for people with disabilities, such as allowing an assistance animal in a no-pets home.
    • Treat families with children the same as other applicants, within lawful occupancy limits.
    • Some small owner-occupied buildings and some single-family homes rented without a broker have narrow exemptions under federal law, but the ban on discriminatory advertising still applies, and state law often removes the exemption.

    How to screen a tenant, step by step

    1. Write your criteria and the order you will process applications.
    2. Publish the criteria and any application fee in the listing or with the application.
    3. Collect a complete application from each adult who will live in the home, with written consent for any reports.
    4. Verify identity with photo ID.
    5. Verify income with pay stubs, an offer letter or bank statements.
    6. Call the last one or two landlords.
    7. Order the credit and eviction reports, and criminal records only if your written policy covers them.
    8. Compare everything with your written criteria and decide.
    9. If any part of the decision rests on a report, send the adverse action notice.
    10. Keep the application, the reports and your notes for the period your state requires, stored securely.
    A man and a woman sitting on the floor among moving boxes after being approved for a rental
    Photo: @silverkblack on Unsplash

    Screening furnished renters on stays of 30 nights or more

    Furnished month-long renters are often screened twice. Many come through a travel nurse agency, an employer relocating staff, or an insurer housing a family after a covered loss. The company has already confirmed who they are and often pays the rent directly, which changes what you need to check.

    When an employer, agency or insurer pays

    Confirm the placement in writing with the company: the renter's name, the dates and who pays. Many owners then focus on identity and rental history rather than income, because the rent is not coming from the renter's paycheck. Apply that rule to every company-placed renter, not case by case.

    When the renter pays

    Screen as you would for a lease, scaled to the stay: income, ID, a reference from a past landlord or host, and the same written criteria for everyone.

    Booking platforms

    Airbnb and Vrbo verify some guest details and run their own policies for longer stays. Check current terms before you rely on a platform's checks in place of your own.

    Common screening mistakes

    • No written criteria, so each applicant is judged a little differently.
    • Taking the first applicant who seems friendly without checking anything.
    • Ordering a report without consent, or denying without the adverse action notice.
    • Calling the current landlord only, who might say anything to see a problem tenant leave.
    • A blanket ban on any criminal record, or on housing vouchers where your state or city forbids it.
    • Listing language that names the kind of person you want rather than the home.
    • Keeping screening files with personal data unsecured.

    What we saw running real homes

    In the homes our team manages, 50 of 616 stays in one year were 28 nights or longer, and those stays brought in 51% of the rental revenue. Most of those renters arrived through a hospital, an employer or an insurer, so the screening question was usually "is this placement confirmed in writing?" rather than "will this person pay?". Rentology's Company Outreach writes to the hospitals, employers and insurers near each home, follows up, and keeps the replies in one inbox, so those placements start with a company already on record.

    A high-rise apartment building seen from below
    Photo: @zarlinaa on Unsplash

    Check one address in the free calculator: lease, furnished 30-night-plus and nightly figures for that home, side by side.

    Questions

    What do landlords check when screening tenants?
    Usually income, rental history, credit and eviction records, identity, and sometimes criminal records, all against written criteria applied the same way to every applicant.
    Do I need permission to run a credit check on a tenant?
    Federal law allows a report for a rental application the applicant started. Get written consent anyway: screening services ask for it and some states require it.
    What is an adverse action notice?
    A notice you must give if a consumer report played a part in denying an application or setting tougher terms. It names the reporting agency, says the agency did not decide, and explains how to get a free copy and dispute it.
    What income should a tenant have?
    Many landlords look for gross monthly income of about three times the rent. Write your rule down, say what counts as income, and apply it to everyone.
    Can I refuse a tenant with a housing voucher?
    Federal law does not ban it, but many states and cities protect source of income. Check your state and city rules first.
    How do I screen a travel nurse or a relocating employee?
    Confirm the placement in writing with the agency or employer, verify identity, and check a past landlord or host. Apply the same rule to every company-placed renter.

    Sources

    1. US Department of Justice: the Fair Housing Act
    2. Fair Housing Act, 42 USC 3604
    3. Fair Credit Reporting Act, 15 USC 1681b (permissible purposes)
    4. Fair Credit Reporting Act, 15 USC 1681m (adverse action duties)
    5. Fair Credit Reporting Act, 15 USC 1681g (consumer's right to their file)

    Why owners run their rentals with Rentology

    Rentology runs leases, furnished stays of 30 nights or more and nightly stays from one place: the calendar, the lease, the monthly payment and the cleaning between stays.

    Company Outreach finds the hospitals, employers and insurers near each of your homes and writes to them for you, so month-long renters come to you.

    • It finds the hospitals, companies and insurers near your homes that book month-long stays, and writes to them for you
    • Answers guests for you, day and night
    • One calendar for every home and every booking
    • Cleaner schedule, door codes and photo inspections for every stay
    • Owner statements and an owner portal, if you manage homes for others

    What 3 homes usually pay each month for the tools Rentology replaces

    • AI guest messaging · HostBuddy$30
    • Cleaning scheduling · Turno$30
    • Phone and AI receptionist · Quo Business + Sona$58
    • Social media scheduling · Buffer Team$30
    • Reels and images · Canva$12
    • E-signature · DocuSign Business Pro$40
    • Team chat · Slack Pro$8.75
    • Dynamic pricing · PriceLabs$22.47
    • Team tasks · Asana Starter$10.99
    • These tools together$242.21
    • Rentology, 3 homes, everything inside$149
    • What you save every month$93.21

    List prices of the named tools in US dollars, per month. Your own booking website, digital guidebooks, work orders and the owner portal are inside Rentology at no extra cost.

    No card. Your first home is set up in about ten minutes.