By Ingo Schaer · Updated 2026
Founder of Rentology. Runs furnished month-long, nightly and long-term rentals with his team.
The short answer
Rent out your house when three things are true: the rent clearly covers every cost of holding the home with money left over, you are happy to be a landlord or pay a manager, and you will not need the money tied up in the house in the next few years. Sell when any one of those is false, or when a sale now saves you tax that renting would cost you later.
Everything else is detail, but the detail decides most cases. This guide walks through the four questions in order: what the house would earn, what it costs to keep, what you want your time and money to do, and what each path means for tax. It ends with a middle path many owners overlook.
Question 1: what would the house earn?
- San Diego, CA$5,500
- Los Angeles, CA$5,100
- New York, NY$4,880
- Austin, TX$4,440
- Phoenix, AZ$4,080
- Dallas, TX$3,940
- Philadelphia, PA$3,540
- Chicago, IL$3,500
- Houston, TX$3,420
- San Antonio, TX$3,340
| City | 12-month lease | Furnished, 30+ nights |
|---|---|---|
| New York, NY | $2,440 | $4,880 |
| Los Angeles, CA | $2,550 | $5,100 |
| Chicago, IL | $1,750 | $3,500 |
| Houston, TX | $1,710 | $3,420 |
| Phoenix, AZ | $2,040 | $4,080 |
| Philadelphia, PA | $1,770 | $3,540 |
| San Antonio, TX | $1,670 | $3,340 |
| San Diego, CA | $2,750 | $5,500 |
| Dallas, TX | $1,970 | $3,940 |
| Austin, TX | $2,220 | $4,440 |
2 bedrooms, per month. Lease: US Census county medians, brought to the 2026 level with the federal rent index. Furnished: twice the lease, the low end of the usual 2 to 2.2 times for stays of 30 nights or more.
Two-bedroom homes in the ten largest US cities, gross per month. The lease column is the median 12-month rent from the Census Bureau's American Community Survey, brought to the current year with the BLS rent index. The furnished column is twice the lease, the start point for stays of 30 nights or more.
For your house, start with your county's median for your bedroom count and HUD's Fair Market Rent, then check three to five similar homes rented nearby. Price both the 12-month lease and the furnished month-long version; they can lead to different answers.
Question 2: what does it cost to keep?
Owners often compare the rent to the mortgage payment and stop there. The real cost of holding a rental is longer.
- Mortgage principal and interest. Principal builds your equity, so it is not lost money, but it is cash out of your pocket each month.
- Property tax, which can rise when the home is no longer your main residence in some states.
- Insurance: a landlord policy usually costs more than a homeowner policy.
- HOA dues, if any.
- Repairs and maintenance. Many owners budget a set share of the rent each year; an older home needs more.
- Empty time between renters, and the clean and repairs at each turnover.
- Management, if you hire it: usually a share of the rent plus a fee to place each new tenant.
- For a furnished stay: furniture, utilities, internet and a clean between renters.
A worked example: rent minus every cost
Numbers make the decision clear. Here is one home run both ways, with simple round figures. Use your own; every market and every mortgage is different.
Worked example (example numbers)
The home rents for $2,000 a month on a 12-month lease. Costs per month: mortgage $1,200, property tax $250, landlord insurance $120, repairs set aside $160, empty time of half a month a year spread out $85, management at 10% $200. Total: $2,015. The lease loses about $15 a month before tax. The same home furnished at twice the lease, $4,000 a month, with extra costs of $300 for utilities and internet, $150 for cleans between renters, $100 for furniture spread over three years, a longer empty-time allowance of one month a year spread out, about $330, and management at a higher share for furnished stays, say 20% or $800: total costs about $3,410 with the same mortgage, tax, insurance and repairs, leaving about $590 a month. The furnished path covers the costs; the lease does not.
Question 3: what do you want your money and time to do?
Do you need the cash?
Selling turns the equity into cash you can use for a down payment on the next home, to pay off debt or to invest elsewhere. Renting keeps it tied up in one house. If you need that cash in the next year or two, renting now and selling later adds the costs of a tenant, a turnover and possibly a lower price for a home with a renter in it.
Do you want to be a landlord?
A 12-month lease is a few hours a month in a good year, and many hours in a bad one: a late payment, a broken water heater at night, a dispute over the deposit. Furnished and nightly stays take more. If you do not want that work, price in a manager.
What does the house do for you over time?
A rental can grow in value, and the tenant pays down your mortgage. A sale ends both. If you plan to move back, or if the home is in an area you expect to grow, keeping it has value beyond the monthly cash.
How far away will you live?
Running a rental from across the country is possible with good local help: a cleaner, a handyman and a manager or software that keeps messages, cleaning and payments in one place. Without that help, distance turns small problems into expensive ones.
Question 4: what each path means for tax
This is general information, not tax advice. The rules below are the federal basics; your state adds its own, and your situation decides which apply. Talk to a tax adviser before you decide.
The home-sale exclusion and its clock
If you sell a home you owned and lived in as your main home for at least 2 of the 5 years before the sale, you can usually exclude up to $250,000 of gain from income, or up to $500,000 for most married couples filing jointly (IRS Topic 701 and Publication 523). Renting the home starts a clock: after about three years as a rental, you no longer meet the 2-of-5 test, and the gain can become taxable. Owners who might sell soon often rent for a shorter time or sell before the window closes.
Depreciation and recapture
While the home is a rental, you deduct depreciation on the building each year (Publication 527 and Publication 946). When you sell, the depreciation allowed is taxed, even if you never claimed it, and the exclusion does not cover it. That gain on depreciation of real property is taxed at a rate of up to 25% (IRS Topic 409).
Rental income and losses
Rent is taxable income; mortgage interest, property tax, insurance, repairs and depreciation are usually deductible (Topic 415). If expenses exceed rent, the loss is often limited by the passive activity rules, which an adviser can explain for your income and situation.
How to decide, step by step
- Estimate the rent two ways: a 12-month lease and a furnished stay of 30 nights or more.
- List every monthly cost of keeping the home, including empty time, repairs and management.
- Subtract costs from each rent figure. If neither is clearly positive, renting is a bet on the home's value going up.
- Get a realistic sale estimate: the likely price minus agent fees, closing costs and repairs a buyer would ask for.
- Ask a tax adviser what a sale now would cost in tax, and what a sale in three or five years would cost after renting.
- Decide how much of your time the rental can take, and what a manager would cost if you want less.
- Choose: sell now, rent with a planned sale date, or rent for the long term. Write the reason down and check it once a year.
When selling is usually the better choice
- The rent does not cover the costs, and you would be paying each month to keep it.
- You need the equity soon for another purchase or to pay down debt.
- You have lived in the home recently enough to sell with the home-sale exclusion, and renting would run the clock out.
- The home needs major work that a tenant would notice and a buyer would price in anyway.
- You do not want to be a landlord and the numbers do not cover a manager.
When renting is usually the better choice
- The rent clearly covers all costs with money left over.
- You locked in a low mortgage rate that would cost more to replace.
- You expect to move back, or expect the area to grow.
- Prices are soft and you can wait for a better market without losing money each month.
- You have good local help, or are willing to pay for it.
A middle path: furnished stays of 30 nights or more
Many owners frame the choice as sell or sign a 12-month lease. A furnished stay of 30 nights or more sits between them. It usually earns well above the lease, the renters are travel nurses, staff on a project and families an insurer is housing, and the home is empty between renters. That matters if you might sell: you can list the home for sale between stays instead of working around a tenant with months left on a lease.
In the homes our team manages, 50 of 616 stays in one year were 28 nights or longer, and those stays brought in 51% of the rental revenue. Those renters rarely search on their own; they come through hospitals, employers and insurers. Rentology's Company Outreach finds those near each home, writes the first email, follows up, and keeps the replies in one inbox.
Common mistakes
- Comparing rent to the mortgage only and calling the difference profit.
- Renting a former home for a few years without checking the home-sale exclusion clock.
- Forgetting that depreciation is taxed on sale.
- Assuming a tenant will keep the home ready for a sale.
- Waiting for a perfect market while the home loses money each month.
How we built this data
- Lease rents: the median gross rent by number of bedrooms for each city's county from the US Census Bureau's American Community Survey, brought forward to the 2026 level with the federal rent index from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Gross rent includes utilities the tenant pays.
- Furnished month-long rent: twice the lease, the low end of the 2 to 2.2 times range owners use for stays of 30 nights or more. A start point to price from, not a quote.
- Every figure is read from our stored copy of these sources when the page loads. We reload all of them once a year, and the year on each table says which one you are reading.
Questions
- Is it better to rent or sell my house?
- Rent when the home clearly earns more than every cost of keeping it, you will run it or pay a manager, and you do not need the cash soon. Sell when any of those is false, and ask a tax adviser about the timing.
- How long can I rent my house before I pay capital gains tax on the sale?
- The home-sale exclusion needs the home to have been your main home for 2 of the 5 years before the sale, so after about three years as a rental you usually lose it. IRS Topic 701 and Publication 523 explain the rule.
- What is depreciation recapture?
- When you sell a rental, the depreciation allowed while it was rented is taxed, at a rate of up to 25% for real property under IRS Topic 409, and the home-sale exclusion does not cover it.
- Should I rent my house if I can't sell it?
- Only if the rent covers the costs or you can accept a monthly loss while you wait. A furnished stay of 30 nights or more keeps the home empty between renters, which makes a later sale simpler.
- How much would my house rent for?
- Start from your county's median rent for your bedrooms and HUD's Fair Market Rent, then check similar homes rented nearby. A furnished stay usually earns about 2 to 2.2 times the lease.
- Do I need a tax adviser to decide?
- For most owners, yes. The exclusion clock, depreciation and state rules change the answer, and the cost of advice is small next to the tax at stake.
Sources
- IRS Topic 701: Sale of your home
- IRS Publication 523: Selling Your Home
- IRS Topic 409: Capital gains and losses: the up-to-25% rate on depreciation of real property
- IRS Publication 527: Residential Rental Property
- IRS Publication 946: How to Depreciate Property
- IRS Topic 415: Renting residential and vacation property
- US Census Bureau, ACS rent by number of bedrooms (B25031)
- HUD Fair Market Rents
- US Census Bureau, American Community Survey program
- Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI rent of primary residence